In September 2021, a nonprofit in Oakland, California sent legal notices to more than fifty sock companies. The claim was narrow and specific: socks made mostly of polyester, with some spandex, exposed wearers to bisphenol A (BPA) without the warning California law requires. Over the next two years the same group filed similar notices on sports bras, athletic shirts, leggings and shorts. If you wear synthetic workout gear or synthetic everyday basics, it is a fair question to ask what was actually found, and what it means for you.
What the Center for Environmental Health found
The Center for Environmental Health (CEH) is a nonprofit that enforces California’s Proposition 65 as a private party. Its BPA campaign on clothing came in three rounds.
| When | Products | CEH’s stated upper bound |
|---|---|---|
| Sept. and Oct. 2021 | Socks for babies, children and adults | Up to 31 times California’s limit |
| Oct. 2022 | Sports bras and athletic shirts | Up to 22 times the limit |
| May 2023 | Leggings, shorts, more bras and shirts | Up to 40 times the limit |
The 2021 sock release said CEH had started action against 63 sock brands. The legal notice itself is titled “Bisphenol A in Socks Made Primarily of Polyester with Spandex.” In October 2022, CEH sent notices to 8 sports bra brands and 6 athletic shirt brands, and said its investigations had found BPA in “polyester-based clothing with spandex.” In May 2023, news coverage reported eight more brands and exposures up to 40 times the limit.
The sports bra notice names two exposure routes: absorption through the skin while the garment is worn, and hand-to-mouth contact after handling it. Most of the coverage focused on women’s gear, but the sock notices covered adults generally, and the fabric at issue, polyester with spandex, is the same blend found in a great deal of men’s underwear, compression shorts and gym shirts.
What a Prop 65 notice means, and what it does not
BPA was added to California’s Prop 65 list in May 2015 as a chemical known to the state to cause reproductive toxicity. For skin contact with solid materials such as fabric, paper and plastic, the state sets a “safe harbor” of 3 micrograms of BPA per day. Under the regulations, that kind of level is derived by taking the dose at which no effect was observed and dividing it by 1,000. Above it, a business needs to warn, reformulate, or argue its exposure is lower.
So “40 times the limit” means CEH estimated a daily exposure around 120 micrograms under its own assumptions about wear. It is worth reading that plainly:
- A notice is an allegation. It is filed by a private enforcer, not issued by a court or a state agency. The notice says CEH intends to sue unless companies recall products, add warnings or reformulate, and pay a penalty.
- The limit has a large built-in margin. Exceeding a Prop 65 safe harbor is a legal trigger for a warning. It is not a measured harm.
- The public numbers are multiples, not measurements. The press releases give exposure as multiples of the limit, not fabric concentrations or the wear model behind them, so readers cannot check the math from the releases alone.
- It is not a verdict on every polyester garment. CEH tested specific products from specific brands.
Why BPA can turn up in polyester
Polyester is not made from BPA. Polyester is usually PET, the same family of plastic used in drink bottles, and BPA is not one of its building blocks. So where does it come from?
The honest answer is that nobody has pinned it down. The European Commission’s Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) reviewed the question in a 2021 opinion and listed several possibilities: BPA used as an intermediate in making antioxidants for textile finishing, BPA derivatives used in fabric coatings, and BPA used as an intermediate in making dyes. It also stated directly that “it is not yet clear, why BPA is present in clothes.”
The committee noted a second possibility. One study it relied on found similar or higher BPA in used clothes than new ones, and saw BPA move between garments in the wash. BPA is common in house dust, so some of what ends up in clothing may arrive after purchase.
The independent lab data are consistent with BPA being widespread in textiles, not limited to one fiber:
- A 2017 study in Environmental Science & Technology tested 77 textiles and infant clothing items. BPA was found in 82% of them, at a mean of 366 ng/g. Socks were highest, with a mean of 1,810 ng/g and a peak of 13,300 ng/g in a 97% polyester fabric.
- A 2019 study in Environment International tested 32 pairs of children’s socks bought in Spain. BPA was in 90.6% of samples. Notably, the socks from the store with the highest BPA levels, about 25 times higher than the other two, had a higher cotton content.
That second finding matters. CEH reported finding BPA only in polyester-spandex clothing. Independent work suggests cotton is not automatically clean either, and that dyes, finishes and handling may matter as much as fiber.
Can BPA be absorbed through the skin?
Yes, BPA can cross skin. The evidence comes mostly from thermal receipt paper, not clothing, which is an important distinction.
Receipt paper carries free BPA as a print developer at high levels. A 2014 PLOS ONE study had volunteers use a hand sanitizer containing penetration-enhancing ingredients, hold receipts, then eat French fries. Serum levels of unconjugated BPA rose to an average peak of about 7 ng/mL within 90 minutes. The same paper found that with dry hands and no sanitizer, urine BPA did not change significantly within an hour. The groups were small, from 3 to 24 people depending on the experiment, and the fries added an oral route.
A 2017 study by Liu and Martin used a labeled form of BPA so it could be traced. Six men handled simulated receipts for five minutes. After eating BPA, their urine levels peaked within 5 hours and cleared within 24. After skin contact, excretion continued steadily for two days, and half of them still had detectable labeled BPA in urine a week later. The authors concluded that skin exposure leads to more prolonged exposure than diet, and may leave a higher share of BPA in its active, unconjugated form.
The SCCS reviewed the skin data and settled on a working figure of about 30% dermal absorption, based mainly on a study using living human skin in the lab and a human kinetics study.
None of these studies measured health outcomes. They show that BPA on the skin can get into the body and linger. They do not show that a given sock or shirt causes harm.
How much BPA comes from clothing, compared with food
The SCCS estimated exposure from clothing under deliberately pessimistic assumptions: two hours a day of the whole trunk in fully sweat-soaked clothes. For adults, it came to 1.56 to 9.90 nanograms per kilogram of body weight per day. The committee judged that to be at least 25 times lower than dietary exposure, and concluded there was no risk of systemic effects from clothing.
There is an important catch. That conclusion was measured against the European Food Safety Authority’s 2015 benchmark of 4 micrograms per kilogram per day. In April 2023, EFSA replaced that benchmark with a tolerable daily intake of 0.2 nanograms per kilogram per day, about 20,000 times lower, based mainly on effects on the immune system in animal studies. The SCCS had said in 2021 that its conclusions might change once EFSA finished. The two figures are not a clean comparison, since one is an internal dose estimate and the other an oral intake benchmark, but the reassurance in the 2021 opinion rests on a number Europe no longer uses.
Regulators also disagree. The US FDA’s current position is that BPA is safe at the levels found in food. EFSA’s view is that typical dietary exposure is already a concern. Clothing sits on top of whichever baseline you accept, and for most people food remains the larger source.
What we don’t know yet
The gaps here are real, and worth stating plainly.
- Migration from fabric to skin. The SCCS noted that only one study had measured BPA moving from clothing into artificial sweat, and that its migration rates were unusually high and needed to be confirmed.
- Where the BPA comes from. Dyes, finishes, coatings and household dust are all candidates. No one has shown which dominates.
- Real-world dose from wearing clothes. No study we found has measured BPA in people’s blood or urine before and after wearing specific garments.
- Health effects at these levels. The human evidence on low-dose BPA is largely associations from population studies, and most of the hazard data come from animals. The clothing question has not been studied for outcomes at all.
- Substitutes. Testing that focuses on BPA can miss related bisphenols such as BPS, which the 2017 textile study also found in about half of samples.
How to reduce your exposure, if you want to
None of these steps are urgent. They are reasonable and cheap.
- Change out of sweaty gear promptly. Sweat and long contact time are what both CEH and the SCCS identify as the drivers of transfer.
- Wash new clothes before wearing them. It is a sensible default for any finish or residue, though no study has shown how much BPA a wash removes, and one found BPA moving between garments in the wash.
- Cut down on receipt handling, especially right after hand sanitizer or lotion. This is the best-studied skin route.
- Look at food first. Fewer canned foods and less heating of food in plastic address the larger source.
- Choose the fabric that sits against your skin all day with some care. Socks and underwear are worn for the most hours, in the warmest places, with the most sweat.
What this means for everyday basics
The CEH notices were about workout gear, but the logic applies to anything you wear close to the skin for long stretches. Underwear is worn more hours than any sports bra. If BPA in textiles is mostly a story about synthetic blends, dyes and finishes, then fewer synthetic fibers and certified dyes reduce the number of places it can come from. They do not reduce it to zero, as the cotton sock data show.
That is the reasoning behind how we built our own product. The Goshen Boxer Brief is 100% GOTS-certified organic cotton with no polyester or spandex in the fabric, dyed with OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified dyes. We have not had it tested for BPA specifically, and we won’t claim otherwise. For a fuller look at what goes into synthetic underwear and how to read labels, see our guide to non-toxic men’s underwear.